Custom Engagement Rings

Why Mehaffey's Jewelry?

For over 80 years, Mehaffey's Jewelry has been one of the most trusted names in jewelry in the Haines City region, proudly serving generations of Central Florida families as their go-to jeweler for brilliant diamonds, fine jewelry, elegant watches, custom designs, and expert repairs. As a family-owned, community-focused business, we're built on a tradition of trust, high ethical standards, and personalized service that makes every customer feel right at home. Our membership in a powerful national buying group lets us deliver exceptional value and a globally-sourced selection while maintaining the individual attention, care, and gemological expertise you can only get from your local jeweler.

Engagement rings are the heart of our business and we take pride in helping craft a ring that will represent your love story and last a lifetime. We have a large selection of engagement ring styles in stock at all times and can work with you to design a fully custom engagement ring as well.

Our 3D ring builder is the best of both worlds – you get to design a fully custom ring and we can have it ready for you in just a couple of weeks at a great price, fully customized around your center stone. Come visit our Haines City showroom to design your custom engagement ring in person or start your journey online using our cutting-edge 3D Ring Builder. Once you have a design you like, schedule an appointment so we can discuss diamond options and finalize your design.